The 11 Best Lip Liners for a Perfect Pout

The 11 Best Lip Liners for a Perfect Pout: A Makeup Artist’s Guide

Lip liners are a game-changer when it comes to enhancing your makeup routine. Whether you want to define your lips, make your lipstick last longer, or create the illusion of fuller lips, the right lip liner can do it all. But with so many options on the market, how do you choose the best one?
We’ve compiled a list of the 11 best lip liners based on expert recommendations, long-lasting formulas, and user-friendly applications. Whether you’re looking for a luxury splurge or a budget-friendly pick, there’s something here for everyone.

1. Best Overall Lip Liner: Pat McGrath Permagel Ultra Lip Pencil

Why We Love It:

                • A silky, feather-resistant formula that stays put
                • Waterproof and transfer-resistant
                • Glides on smoothly without tugging

This Pat McGrath lip liner is a holy grail product for many makeup artists. It delivers a flawless finish with rich pigment and a creamy texture that doesn’t smudge. The formula is designed to last for hours, making it perfect for long days or special events.

What Could Be Better: The pencil wears down quickly, so frequent sharpening is needed.

2. Best Drugstore Lip Liner: NYX Slim Lip Pencil

Best Drugstore Lip Liner: NYX Slim Lip Pencil

Why We Love It:

                • Affordable without compromising on quality
                • Infused with jojoba oil and shea butter for hydration
                • Comes in a variety of shades

NYX is a go-to brand for affordable, high-quality makeup, and their Slim Lip Pencil is no exception. This liner provides precise application with a smooth glide, making it ideal for beginners and experts alike.

What Could Be Better: A slightly thicker pencil would make it more versatile for filling in the lips.

3. Best Luxury Lip Liner: Sisley Paris Phyto-Lèvres Perfect

Sisley Paris Phyto-Lèvres Perfect

Why We Love It:

                • Infused with skincare benefits like aloe vera and jojoba oil
                • Moisturizing formula that prevents dryness
                • Comes with a built-in brush for blending

For those who love a little luxury, the Sisley Paris lip liner is a great pick. It offers a smooth, precise application while nourishing your lips with hydrating ingredients.

What Could Be Better: The formula has a satiny finish, which may not be ideal for those who prefer a matte look.

4. Best Shade Range: ColourPop Lippie Pencil

Best Shade Range: ColourPop Lippie Pencil

Why We Love It:

                • Available in over 30 shades
                • Long-lasting formula that prevents feathering
                • Affordable and highly pigmented

ColourPop’s Lippie Pencil is a fan favorite, thanks to its extensive shade range and creamy formula. Whether you prefer neutrals or bold colors, you’ll find a perfect match.

What Could Be Better: The formula could be more hydrating.

5. Best Long-Wearing Lip Liner: NARS Powermatte High-Intensity Lip Pencil

Best Long-Wearing Lip Liner: NARS Powermatte High-Intensity Lip Pencil

Why We Love It:

                • Lasts up to 12 hours
                • Can be used as both a liner and a lipstick
                • Highly pigmented with a matte finish

This NARS lip liner is perfect for those who want a product that stays in place all day. It’s transfer-proof and smudge-resistant, making it a great choice for busy days.

What Could Be Better: The bullet is slightly thicker, making it less precise for lining.

6. Best Smudge-Proof Lip Liner: Dior Rouge Dior Contour No-Transfer Lip Liner Pencil

Best Smudge-Proof Lip Liner: Dior Rouge Dior Contour No-Transfer Lip Liner Pencil

Why We Love It:

                • Smudge-proof and precise
                • Infused with nourishing ingredients like shea butter and pomegranate extract
                • Comes with a built-in brush

Dior’s lip liner is great for those who want long-lasting definition without worrying about smudging. It pairs well with various lipstick finishes.

What Could Be Better: Could use more deep shade options.

7. Best Waterproof Lip Liner: Make Up For Ever Artist Color Pencil Extreme Lip Liner

Why We Love It:

                • Waterproof and transfer-proof
                • Velvety matte finish with intense color
                • Long-lasting formula perfect for all-day wear

For those who need a budge-proof lip liner, this Makeup For Ever option is a must-have. It holds up against meals, drinks, and even showers.

What Could Be Better: The creamy texture makes it less precise than traditional liners.

8. Best Hydrating Lip Liner: Ilia Lip Sketch Hydrating Crayon

Why We Love It:

                • Infused with skincare ingredients like hyaluronic acid and seaweed extract
                • Hydrates while defining lips
                • Medium-tip for both lining and filling in lips

This Ilia liner is perfect for those who struggle with dry lips. It keeps your lips moisturized while providing long-lasting color.

What Could Be Better: The sharpener needed for precise lines is sold separately.

9. Best Lip Liner for Sensitive Skin: Charlotte Tilbury Lip Cheat

Why We Love It:

                • Infused with nourishing ingredients like beeswax and jojoba oil
                • Smooth, creamy formula
                • Works well for overlining lips naturally

If you have sensitive skin, this Charlotte Tilbury lip liner is a great choice. It’s gentle on the lips while delivering rich, long-lasting color.

What Could Be Better: Runs out quickly and requires frequent sharpening.

10. Most Versatile Lip Liner: Buxom Power Line Plumping Lip Liner

Most Versatile Lip Liner: Buxom Power Line Plumping Lip Liner

Why We Love It:

                • Slanted tip for easy application
                • Doesn’t require sharpening
                • Infused with vitamin E and avocado oil for hydration

Buxom’s Power Line Lip Liner is great for on-the-go applications. Its twist-up design eliminates the need for sharpening, and the slanted tip makes defining and filling effortless.

What Could Be Better: A clear cap for the brush end would make it easier to distinguish from the pencil side.

11. Best Lip Liner for Contouring: Makeup By Mario Ultra Suede Sculpting Lip Pencil

Why We Love It:

                • Full-coverage matte finish
                • Adjustable sharpness for precision
                • Built-in brush for blending

Makeup By Mario’s lip liner is perfect for sculpting and defining the lips. Its firm yet creamy formula allows for precise application.

What Could Be Better: The brush cap can become loose over time.

How To Find the Right Lip Liner for Yourself?

1. Matching the Liner to Your Lip Color

For Natural Looks:

When you’re aiming for a more natural, “no-makeup” makeup look, choosing a lip liner that closely matches your natural lip color is the best option. This will help define your lips without making them look overly done. For example, if you have a light pinkish or beige lip colour, opt for a liner in a similar soft pink or nude shade.

For Bold Looks:

If you’re using a bold or intense lipstick color (like red, fuchsia, or dark berry), it’s important to match the liner to the lipstick. This creates a seamless transition between the lips and liner, helping to prevent any awkward lines or bleeding. For example, if you’re wearing a classic red lipstick, you’d want a red liner, but one that’s slightly deeper in tone for a more defined look.

2. Understanding Undertones

Just like with foundation and blush, lip liners also work best when they complement your skin’s undertone.

Warm Undertones (golden, yellow, or olive)

If you have warm undertones, lip liners with warm, brown, peach, or coral shades are ideal. They blend effortlessly into your lip’s natural color and give a rich, flattering effect. For instance, a warm brown liner can pair beautifully with peach, nude, or red shades.

Cool Undertones ( pink, blue, or rosy):

For cool undertones, lip liners with cooler tones such as pink, berry, mauve, or plum work best. These liners will complement the pink or red hues in your lips and prevent the lips from looking too muted or washed out. A cool pink liner works wonderfully with a soft pink lipstick or a berry shade.

Neutral Undertones (a mix of warm and cool):

If you have neutral undertones, you’re lucky because most colors will work well for you. Neutral lip liners are usually pinky-brown shades that match a wide range of lipstick colors, from nudes to rich reds.

3. Texture of the Lip Liner

The texture of your lip liner affects both application and longevity:

Matte Lip Liners:

Matte formulas are often more durable and long-lasting. They don’t smudge as easily, making them great for all-day wear. However, matte liners can feel drier on the lips, so they may not be ideal if you have naturally dry lips. If you go matte, consider pairing with a hydrating lip balm to keep lips comfortable.

Creamy Lip Liners:

Creamy liners tend to glide on smoothly, making them easier to apply, especially for beginners. They offer a more moisturizing feel compared to matte formulas but may not last as long, especially if you’re drinking or eating. You might need to reapply throughout the day.

Gel Lip Liners:

Gel liners are a hybrid of both creamy and matte formulas. They tend to be highly pigmented, offering smooth application and long-lasting results. Gel liners can provide the best of both worlds if you’re looking for something that applies easily but stays put.

4. Defining Your Lips

Lip liners are great for shaping and defining your lips:

Overlining:

If you want to make your lips appear fuller, overlining (slightly drawing outside the natural lip line) can be effective. However, it’s important not to go too far outside the natural contour to avoid the appearance of an unnatural, harsh line. When overlining, it’s best to use a liner that’s close to your natural lip color or one that is slightly deeper than your lipstick shade to ensure it blends seamlessly.

Underlining:

For a more defined look, applying a slightly darker liner than your lipstick color along the natural lip line can give your lips structure and definition. This can be especially helpful with bold or vibrant lip colors that might need a little extra precision.

5. Test Before You Buy

The lighting in stores can sometimes deceive you, so it’s always important to test the liner before making your purchase. The best way to test is to apply the product directly to your lips or on the back of your hand to see how it looks against your skin tone. Ideally, you want to check the liner’s consistency, how easily it glides on, and whether the color is close to what you were expecting.

If you’re shopping online, look at swatches and reviews. Many makeup brands offer online swatches or even user-generated photos, which can give you an idea of how the product performs in real life.

6. Choosing Between Retractable or Traditional Pencils

Retractable Pencils:

These are convenient because they don’t require sharpening. You can just twist them up for more product. They’re great for on-the-go use, but you might lose a bit of precision compared to sharpenable pencils.

Traditional Pencils:

Traditional wooden pencils or twist-up pencils that need sharpening offer more precision and are ideal for detailed lip work. However, they can require more maintenance and a sharpener, and they sometimes don’t glide on as easily as creamier formulas.

7. Long-Lasting Formulas

For a liner that stays in place all day, look for a long-lasting or waterproof formula. Many brands offer smudge-proof lip liners that promise to withstand eating, drinking, and talking. These formulas often have a slightly more waxy texture, which helps them stay put without budging. If you’re looking for extra staying power, opt for a liner that also doubles as a lip color or has a more matte finish.

Tips for Application:

  • Prep Your Lips: Exfoliate your lips gently to remove any dry patches before applying the liner. Hydrate with a lip balm to keep your lips smooth.
  • Line and Fill: For a more defined lip, outline the edges of your lips first, then fill in the center with the same liner to create a more solid base for your lipstick.
  • Blending: If you’re using a bold or deep color, you might want to blend the liner slightly into the lips with your finger or a lip brush to avoid a stark contrast.

With these top picks, you’ll be able to find the perfect lip liner for your needs. Whether you’re after long wear, hydration, or the perfect nude shade, these recommendations have got you covered!

Frequently Asked Questions

Absolutely! Lip liner can be worn alone to create a matte, long-lasting lip color. Simply line and fill in your lips completely with your chosen shade. To avoid dryness, apply a lip balm beforehand or a gloss on top for added shine. This technique is especially useful for creating a "your lips but better" (MLBB) look with a nude liner that enhances your natural lip color.

To keep your lip liner in place all day, follow these tips:

  • Choose a long-wearing or waterproof formula to prevent smudging.
  • Prime your lips with a bit of foundation or concealer before applying the liner.
  • Set the liner by dabbing a small amount of translucent powder over it.
  • Avoid overly creamy formulas that may slip and slide throughout the day.
  • Apply in thin layers rather than a thick, waxy application, which can lead to smudging.

Finding the right nude lip liner depends on your skin tone and undertone:

  • Fair Skin: Opt for soft pink, light peach, or beige tones to enhance natural lip color.
  • Medium Skin: Warm beige, rosy nudes, or mauve shades work best.
  • Olive Skin: Caramel, brownish nudes, or warm terracotta shades complement olive undertones.
  • Dark Skin: Deep brown, berry, or chocolate shades define the lips beautifully.

Choosing the right nude lip liner ensures a natural and polished look, whether you're wearing it alone or under lipstick.

Most retractable lip liners are designed to be twisted up and do not require sharpening. However, some brands include a built-in sharpener at the end of the liner to maintain a precise tip. If your liner becomes dull and doesn’t have a sharpener, you can try gently shaping the tip with a tissue. Always twist up only a small amount to avoid breakage and extend the liner’s lifespan.

pubherald

pubherald

Keep in touch with our news & offers

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

What to Read next...

Trump Administration Ends Deportation Protection for 500,000 Haitians

The U.S. government has announced that Temporary Protected Status (TPS) for approximately 500,000 Haitians living in the country will end on August 3, 2025. This decision, confirmed by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) on Thursday, means that affected individuals will lose their work permits and could face deportation.The termination of TPS comes despite ongoing …

DeepSeek: The Chinese AI Model That Took the World by Surprise

In the world of artificial intelligence (AI), breakthroughs are often expected to come from well-established giants like OpenAI, Google, or Microsoft. However, on January 20, 2025, a Chinese-made AI model named DeepSeek managed to steal the spotlight and turn the industry upside down. In a matter of days, it climbed to the top of Apple’s …

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *